Choice and consequences statistics are combined percentages of all players and are displayed after completing a chapter of Tell Me Why.
The bond symbol and picture of the twins changes depending on their understanding/trust status.
- The page was last updated on September 9, 2020.
Chapter 1 - Homecoming[]
Tyler & Alyson[]
- Alyson was happy that Tyler accepted Eddy's peace offering.
- Alyson was disappointed that Tyler didn't accept Eddy's peace offering.
- Alyson was furious Tyler disregarded Eddy and his gift.
- 77% accepted the ring
- 14% refused the ring
- 9% threw the ring in the water
- Alyson was delighted to solve the Princess' riddle with her brother.
- Alyson felt downhearted that Tyler refused to solve the Princess's riddle.
- 86% solved the door puzzle
- 14% busted open the door puzzle
- Tyler felt supported by Alyson's trust at the store.
- Tyler felt unrecognized by Alyson's lack of trust at the store.
- 54% chose Tyler's memory
- 46% chose Alyson's memory
- Tyler was reassured of his bond to Alyson when she sided with him at the station.
- Tyler sensed a rift between him and Alyson when she sided with Eddy at the station.
- 70% sided with Tyler
- 30% sided with Eddy
Sam Kansky[]
- Tyler protected himself against Sam's aggression.
- Tyler earned Sam's respect.
- 53% called out Sam
- 47% didn't called out Sam
Tessa Vecchi[]
- Tessa opened up to the twins about Mary-Ann.
- Tessa shut out the twins about Mary-Ann.
- 51% learned the truth
- 23% didn't get an answer
- 26% antagonized Tessa
Eddy Brown[]
- Eddy felt validated by Alyson's family plea when she sided with him at the station.
- Eddy felt rejected by Alyson when she didn't side with him at the station.
- 30% sided with Eddy
- 70% sided with Tyler
Chapter 2 - Family Secrets[]
Tyler & Alyson[]
- Tyler felt relied on when Alyson chose his memory at the house.
- Tyler felt Alyson discarded his feelings when choosing her memory at the house.
- 52% chose Tyler's memory
- 48% chose Alyson's memory
- Tyler didn't feel heard about needing time when Alyson accepted the house showing.
- Tyler felt heard about needing time when Alyson refused the house showing.
- 37% accepted the appointment
- 63% refused the appointment
- Alyson felt let down when Tyler couldn't forgive Eddy.
- Alyson felt hopeful about becoming a family when Tyler forgave Eddy.
- 82% forgave Eddy
- 18% didn't forgave Eddy
Eddy Brown[]
- Eddy was touched by Tyler's forgiveness.
- Eddy was sorry that Tyler couldn't forgive him.
- 82% forgave Eddy
- 18% didn't forgave Eddy
Micheal Abila[]
- Michael was heartened by Tyler's compliment.
- Michael felt awkward after Tyler turned him down.
- 78% accepted Michael's compliment
- 22% turned down Michael
Tessa Vecchi[]
- Tessa felt grateful the twins kept her in their lives.
- Tessa felt rejected by the twins.
- 82% forgave Tessa
- 18% didn't forgave Tessa
Chapter 3 - Inheritance[]
Tyler & Alyson[]
- Alyson was grateful they completed Mary-Ann's puzzle
- 13% forced the chest open
- 87% completed the puzzle
- Alyson felt that standing by the twins' memory was the right thing.
- Alyson was influenced by Tom's testimony.
- 80% believed in Tom's testimony
- 20% believed in the twins' memory
- The twins trusted their bond and kept their voice.
- 0% let go of their voice
- 100% held on to their voice
Eddy Brown[]
Eddy was relieved that Alyson accepted responsibility in the murder.
- 73% confessed the truth
- 27% did not confess the truth
Sam Kansky[]
Sam felt understood by Alyson
Sam lashed out at Alyson
- 20% confronted Sam with his addiction
- 80% listened to Sam's story
Michael Abila[]
Michael felt closer to Tyler.
- 73% kissed Michael
- 27% did not kiss Michael